top of page

Review of "The Uprising"

Nov 8
3 min read


John Ball greets Wat Tyler, Froissart's Chronicles - Detail of British Library manuscript "Royal 18 E. I f.165v"
John Ball greets Wat Tyler, Froissart's Chronicles - Detail of British Library manuscript "Royal 18 E. I f.165v"

A review of the film The Uprising, directed by Paul Greengrass


I have to admit, straight away, I was slightly disappointed with this film. My verdict is that Paul Greengrass's The Uprising is a film at war with itself. On one hand, it is a visceral, mud-caked recreation of the 1381 Peasants' Revolt, boasting a committed performance from Andrew Garfield and the director's signature kinetic energy. On the other hand, it is a muddled and heavy-handed historical epic that never quite figures out what it wants to say about the past, or the present, ultimately collapsing under the weight of its own anachronisms and a bafflingly unnecessary epilogue. There is always a danger when a film is committed to a cause: taking a particular stance, you risk creating propaganda which undermines a viewer coming to their own conclusions!


The plot of the film follows Garfield's "Ploughman," a grieving farmer who, after losing his family to the plague, sparks a rebellion against the crushing taxes of the boy-king Richard II. He soon joins forces with the historical figures of Wat Tyler (Cosmo Jarvis) and John Ball (Jamie Bell) to march on London. Greengrass's trademark handheld, documentary-style camerawork is deployed here to immersive effect, thrusting the viewer into the filth and fury of 14th-century England. At its best, this approach makes the battle sequences feel urgent and chaotic, capturing the "fog of war" with a visceral intensity that is undeniably thrilling.

However, this stylistic choice is also one of the film's primary liabilities. Critics have noted that the shaky-cam aesthetic, so effective in modern thrillers like Captain Phillips, feels jarringly anachronistic in a medieval setting. The constant movement and snap-zooms draw attention to the camera itself, shattering the illusion of the period and leaving some viewers feeling less immersed. The result is a film that feels less like a window into the past and more like a modern news report awkwardly grafted onto a historical reenactment.


The screenplay, penned by Greengrass, struggles to balance its historical obligations with its contemporary ambitions. The parallels to modern political life are not so much drawn as they are bludgeoned into the audience. When an establishment figure dismissively refers to the peasants as "deplorables," the film's heavy hand is laid bare, prompting eye-rolls rather than introspection. While the underlying themes of wealth inequality and a disconnected ruling class are undeniably potent, the script lacks the nuance to explore them effectively, preferring instead to shout its message through a megaphone. The narrative also suffers from a lack of focus, with the fictional Ploughman often feeling like a passive observer swept along by events rather than a compelling protagonist driving them.


Where the film does find solid footing is in its performances. Andrew Garfield brings a soulful, weary dignity to the Ploughman, grounding the chaotic events with a palpable sense of grief and simmering rage. He is well-supported by Cosmo Jarvis and Jamie Bell, who bring a rough-hewn authenticity to their roles as the historical firebrands Tyler and Ball. The film's depiction of the revolt itself also deserves credit for refusing to romanticise the violence; as the rebellion gains momentum, it morphs into a terrifying mob, and the film does not shy away from showing the ugly, indiscriminate cruelty that accompanies the breakdown of order.


Ultimately, The Uprising is a frustrating experience. It is a film with a strong central performance, a timely message, and moments of genuine cinematic power, all of which are undermined by a lack of discipline and a fundamental misunderstanding of its own strengths. The most egregious misstep is its epilogue, a clumsy attempt to retroactively frame the story as a Robin Hood origin tale. This addition feels like a cynical marketing ploy, one that cheapens the history the film spent two hours attempting to dramatise. The result is a historical epic that is as likely to leave you checking your watch as it is to move you, a muddled slog through the muck that never quite finds its footing. Shame - a missed opportunity.


Tim Boatswain, 8th November, 2026




 

 

 
 
 

Comments


Subscribe Form

07873586074

©2020 by Anthropology and History. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page